Article

소크라테스적 종교는 가능한가?

황필호 1 ,
Philip H. Hwang 1 ,
Author Information & Copyright
1한국, 강남대학교
Corresponding Author : Hwang, Philip H.

ⓒ Copyright 2004, The Daesoon Academy of Sciences. This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Published Online: Jun 30, 2004

Abstract

Socrates did not found a religion, and in this sense he is different from Confucius, Buddha and Jesus. So there can be no ‘Socrates’ religion. But if we can assume that there are evidently religious aspects in his thought, and if it can become a religion by expanding these aspects, then we may conclude that ‘Socratic religion’ is possible.

In general, there are three arguments to regard Socrates as a religious person. The first is to see him as a precursor of Christianity or a Christian martyr, the second is to regard Socrates’ daimonion as identical with Christian revelation, and the third is to argue that Socrates was a religious person because of his firm belief in the immortality of soul. But in this paper, I argue that these three arguments offer some justifications but insufficient to conclude that he was a religious person.

Shall we conclude then that not only Socratic religion is impossible but also he was not a religious person? I do not think so. For there are two counter arguments.

Religious truths have at least two essential characteristics. First, those who have religious truths are absolutely happy, no matter what. This is why Socrates as a religious person could advise his disciples to improve their souls even at the time of his death bed. Second, those who have religious truths do love others, no matter what. How could it be possible for someone to love invisible ultimate reality if he did not love visible brothers? This is why Socrates as a religious person took his mission to philosophize as a divine command.

Socrates did not initiate any official religion, but he was truly a devout religious person, who transcended the boundary of institutionalized religion. It follows that Socratic religion is evidently possible.

Keywords: 소크라테스; 영력; 영혼 불멸; 종교적 진리
Keywords: Socrates; daimonion; immortality of soul; religious truth

<참고문헌>

1.

박종현, 『희랍사상의 이해』, 서울, 종로서적, 1982.

2.

황필호, 『한국 巫敎의 특성과 문제점』, 서울, 집문당, 2002.

3.

황필호, 『엔도 슈사꾸의 종교소설 읽기』, 서울, 신아출판사, 2002.

4.

황필호, 『중국종교철학 산책』, 서울, 청년사, 2001.

5.

황필호, 『문학철학 산책』, 서울, 집문당, 1996.

6.

디아네 콜린스, 김동림 역, 『철학의 큰스승 50』, 서울, 책세상, 1989.

7.

존힉, 황필호 역, 『종교철학 개론』, 서울, 종로서적, 1980.

8.

모리모토 데츠로, 양억관 역, 『소크라테스 최후의 13일』, 서울, 푸른숲, 1997.

9.

칼 야스퍼스, 황필호 역, 『소크라테스, 공자, 석가, 예수, 모하메드』, 경기도용인, 강남대, 2001.

10.

Gregory Vlastos, ed. The Philosophy of Socrates, Anchor Books, 1971.

11.

Mark L. McPherran, The Religion of Socrates, Pennsylvania State University Press, 1996.

12.

Reginald E. Allen, ed. Greek Philosophy: Thales to Aristotle, Macmillan, 1966.

13.

W. K. C. Guthrie, Socrates, Cambridge University Press, 1971.

14.

W. K. C. Guthrie, The Greek Philosophers, Harper Torchbooks, 1960.